P&G To Lay Off 1,600 After Discovering It’s Free To Advertise On Facebook

“Reality appears to have finally arrived at Procter & Gamble, the world’s largest marketer, whose $10 billion annual ad budget has hurt the company’s margins. P&G said it would lay off 1,600 staffers, including marketers, as part of a cost-cutting exercise. More interestingly, CEO Robert McDonald finally seems to have woken up to the fact that he cannot keep increasing P&G’s ad budget forever, regardless of what happens to its sales”.

Talk about a reality check!

For those that may not be aware, P&G is world renowned as arguably the #1 consumer goods marketer in the world. To think they have “just woken up” to the power of Facebook and potentially other social media is mind-boggling.

The shift in emphasis has been coming for more than just a couple of years, and even the business to business marketing world has been debating and testing the social media waters for quite a while.

So, if the world’s leading marketers don’t get it, how do we expect non-marketers to deal with the social media issue? While some people are flocking to social media for any and all (not always well thought out) reasons, others seem to be somewhat gun shy. It is clear that one can rationalize use of social media in B2C environments much more easily than in B2B environments, simply because the avarage consumer is more engaged with it as an active means of communication and interaction. While the B2B consumer is headed that way, it is much less significant and important to them.

One of the most important issues for people adopting a new marketing approach is to have a really well thought out reason why they feel that adopting social media is better than their traditional approaches. The FREE and EASY philosophy of social media is a fallacy. $ and cents is not the only limited resource that people have. Time, focus and energy are just a few of the other resources that need to be taken into consideration, and they are often forgotten or ignored.

So don’t fall into the trap – think it through properly and try to get ahead of the game. The front of the line is a much safer and more advantageous place to be. Just ask P&G who now have to plat catch-up. Inevitably they will succeed becasue they are really good and have tons of money to throw at it. But for the average Joe out there – think first (very carefully) before you leap (or decide not to leap) into the social media world that will inevitably become an important part of your future.

Read the full article

Neville Pokroy consults in the areas of strategic marketing planning, as well as in the development and execution of marketing strategies and plans. He assists companies who require marketing expertise to plan and fully execute marketing programs. If you want to have more choice in marketing your business and in setting yourself apart, and increase the odds of improving company performance, visit our website.

Market research as an industry is dying…true or false?

I recently posted this question on a public forum and was quite intrigued by the answers. The question further addressed the issue that online surveys may be impacting the answer because it encourages a DIY (Do-It-Yourself) approach to research. Like anything, differing views provide tremendous insight that one can learn from and adapt. Here are just some of the comments – see what you think:

“Having DIY survey tools means that researchers must strive harder to analyze information creatively and add value to pure survey data. Plus having good tools to administer surveys does not guarantee a good questionnaire design, which is absolutely key too, and for which you need expertise”.

“We have always had DIY surveys. The internet simply made it easier, quicker and cheaper. Historically it has been good for the industry because it made companies research aware and it also makes them realize it is only good for the simple stuff that they probably wouldn’t get a budget for anyway. As an industry we must stop lumping internet and DIY together or even worse internet and access panels. The internet is one of our best media but its association with access panels has undermined its reputation”.

“Yeah it’s being destroyed, just like the automobile destroyed the bike. Guess again…DIY research has a place, it’s a quick, cheap, easy entry opportunity that individuals and organizations would be foolish not to take advantage. But those are projects that in the past probably would not have reached our channel anyways. DIY online research is like painting your house…yes everyone can do it, but can everyone do it well? Then again, some people are destined to live in trailers”.

“I don’t think the arrival of DIY represents the all-encompassing business model shift one would fear. As such the resulting implication of this trend on the overall MR industry would be minimal because the expertise and knowledge of a trained and experienced MR professional cannot be replaced by DIY tool, but only be complemented”.

“The large MR firms may be in trouble. I remember trying to engage with (name witheld) for a project and their response back to me was “we only do long-term engagements.” I’ve since met with a friend who went to work for them and noted that to her. Her response was “No wonder they’ve been doing so poorly”. At the same time, firms with proprietary processes have a solid niche because they have something different to offer that justifies their price point.”.

“I disagree. Sure there are fringes of the research world that are suitable for DIY, however there will always be the need for the size and scale projects that cannot be done in-house”.

“I preferred firms when I knew all of the people working on my projects, their strengths and limitations. One of the major distinctions among research companies is whether they separate sales and operations. Some don’t, and the people with whom you’ve talked are the people doing the work. Most do, and the person writing the questionnaire and report is someone totally invisible to you. I prefer the former model, although it can be difficult, since you have to do what the professional sales people do, plus questionnaires, analysis and reports”.

“I think what the MR world is seeing is exactly what the traditional Ad Agency world has been seeing. When these big companies forget where their profits are coming from and get stuck in the “when you have a hammer everything looks like a nail” mindset, there is bound to be some kickback”.

“The Market Research that we knew – pen/paper, face to face – is disappearing, convenience sampling is replacing probability sampling, technology is changing the way e.g. we do concept research, in-store….lots is changing. Dying? No – a rebirth”.

“DIY survey tools do have their place – however to gain the best insights and to receive the best value for money, employing the services of an experienced research agency to guide you through the process can give the research far more depth and accuracy – not to mention further analysis capabilities”.

“Q. Heard the one about the lawyer who hired himself to represent him? A. He had a fool as a client. DIY has a role in most anything: Interior design, landscaping, plumping, car maintenance, etc etc. Surely it has a place in marketing research as well, even more so with the overwhelming # of DIY MR tools available. However, serious business decisions made my responsible decision makers will always lean heavily on MR experts with robust tools”.

“Massively disagree. Whether you hire a research company or do the research yourself, you still need people who are skilled researchers to do the work. Researchers are researchers wherever they sit. Now, if you want to talk about crap research vs quality research, that’s completely different question”.

“New technologies often have a disruptive impact – the widespread availability of low/ no cost survey software plus the easy access to “the consumer” via online panels, social media makes it an exciting time to be in MR. Things are opening up – great! MR can extend its reach, entrenched survey costs are challenged – I think it’s immensely healthy for MR. Why on earth should DIY kill the industry? I’d say it’s like a wake-up call, a shot in the arm – it expands the market, and some bits of it may be challenged”.

“What I believe we will see if a combination or opportunity and luck from start-ups and SMBs who try the DIY approach and come reasonably close to asking the right questions or the right people (other will botch the job and vanish in a puff of insolvency). Larger companies will supplement rigorous research with crowdsourced info and spot surveys”.

“The ability to collect data IS becoming easier through the DIY approach of online surveys. That doesn’t mean the results are actionable or representative. Research will always have a place in the interpretation of collected data. Market research, like any other industry, is evolving. We see more reference to “insights” versus research”.

“Market research is one of the most misunderstood practices in marketing. In today’s environment, anybody (literally anybody) can gather information using any channel they wish. The real market research skill is not related to gathering this information. It is rather about what one really can make out of this information, what it really means, what perspectives they can develop and most importantly how gutsy one can become in predicting the future based on this information. This is not an easy task and the underlying prerequisite for successful activity in this area relates to how well a marketing person knows the targets and their environment, so I do not believe market research is dying”.

“Will a C level exec really make a decision that truly influences the business and impacts the bottom line, either through revenue streams or expenditures, through some half-ass survey completed online by research want-to-be’s? Probably not…. they would want a consultant that understands their business, using statistical models to support the findings and probably some qualitative info. So… in the end, it depend on what decisions are being made and/or how much money is at stake to determine the resource needs for research and insights”.

“I doubt formal market research will ever die specifically because precision in targeting (at least in B2B) is essential. B2C plays can learn through market experimentation, which is ad hoc research”.

“I think the answer’s the same. We’ve lost the need for quality. Based on an incomplete understanding of the value of the process of the sale (and in fact a devaluation of the consumer and their needs), we (or our clients) simply take the money and run. Personally, I think we’ve got to adapt our minds to our machines and try to get back to 80-90% of the quality of information we used to get”.

“The tool has caused a disruptive change/innovation. Expectations for what the new social and digital tools will do for us are high. But in many ways, one can see the parallel increase in demand for quality marketing research in new areas and domains where it was not cost effective or otherwise not possible to do until now. This in turn increases the demand for the professional people that know how to do this. The tools don’t replace the people that know the science”.

“No matter what tools you choose to use, they still must be used properly, the vehicle for gathering information appropriate to the project’s goals. There have always been poorly designed studies, that yield erroneous research data, that lead to bad decisions, that lead to waste – that won’t change whether you use social media, web analytics or paper questionnaires. Bad use of tools doesn’t signal the death knell of marketing research, just the prevalence of amateur practitioners”.

Thanks to all those that contributed. I certainly appreciate the time and intensity that you provided.

Neville Pokroy consults in the areas of strategic marketing planning, as well as in the development and execution of marketing strategies and plans. He assists companies who require marketing expertise to plan and fully execute marketing programs. If you want to have more choice in marketing your business and in setting yourself apart, and increase the odds of improving company performance, visit our website.

2012 – fresh thinking but not necessarily a new beginning

Prosperity.  Hope.  Success.  These are just some of the things we all look for as a new year begins.  Nothing wrong with that!  But how do we get there if we continue to do the same things we did last year – and the year before that.

Here are a few ideas to get us thinking differently without having to challenge ourselves to create a totally new beginning for our future…

Learn from the past and create new behaviours – history has always been our greatest teacher.  However, we sometimes forget to apply a changed mindset to those learnings, and we often fall back into what was comfortable.  This is often deadly if that behaviour has not been successful in the past.  So, today’s challenge is: identify 2 or 3 things only that you can learn from the past, then write down what changes you will make in that regard and pin those changes on a board next to your desk.  Make sure you will see that note every day, and live by the changes.  You will find those behaviours will soon become your new norm.

Stay calm and don’t panic – look for small wins and set yourself realistic goals.  When we set goals that are too lofty and challenging we often become panicked by the challenges we perceive.  Set yourself realistic goals and celebrate them with your team when you achieve them.  Panicking will not accomplish anything.

Learn something new – particularly something that will either change the way you look at things, or the way you deal with things.  It could also be something specific to your business by upgrading your skill set.  Remember, we are in an ever-changing environment.  If you are not growing while the world is changing around you, you will be going backwards.

Never stop striving – if you feel you have “arrived”, be careful.  The world is continuing to evolve so you need to keep pushing forward.  As Thomas J Watson once said: “Whenever an individual or a business decides that success has been attained, progress stops”.

Laugh more – you’re probably thinking this is a strange one.  However laughter is the best medicine for the soul, so the more you laugh the clearer you will be able to think.  Try it – you’ll be surprised how well it works.

Finally, Believe in yourself – James R. Cook said it best: “Do just once what others say you can’t do, and you will never pay attention to their limitations again”.

Good luck in 2012 – and keep thinking fresh.

Neville Pokroy consults in the areas of strategic marketing planning, as well as in the development and execution of marketing strategies and plans. He assists companies who require marketing expertise to plan and fully execute marketing programs.  If you want to have more choice in marketing your business and in setting yourself apart, and increase the odds of improving company performance, visit our website.